A Different Approach to Rental Affordability, Safety and Standards. Would Rental Star Ratings Help?
Updated: Oct 27
Imagine two rental properties in the same suburb.
The first is an older house renting for $420 a week. It is structurally sound, electrically safe, weatherproof and free from dangerous mould. The kitchen and bathroom work perfectly well. But it has little insulation, single-glazed windows and limited heating and cooling.
The second home rents for $560 a week. It has good insulation, efficient reverse-cycle heating and cooling, better glazing, modern hot water and considerably lower energy consumption.
Which home should a renter be allowed to choose? The obvious answer may seem to be: either.
But as minimum rental standards continue to expand, there is a broader question worth asking.
Should every safe rental property ultimately be required to provide broadly the same minimum level of comfort and energy efficiency?

Or could Victoria, and perhaps Australia, consider something different:
A rental star-rating system could separate mandatory health and safety standards from comfort and energy-efficiency standards. Every property would first have to pass non-negotiable safety requirements. Safe properties could then be rated from ★ Essential to ★★★★★ Premium according to other criteria, such as insulation, heating, cooling, glazing, energy efficiency and amenities. Renters would see the rating before applying and decide whether the additional comfort was worth the additional rent.
This isn't an argument against safe rental housing. Quite the opposite.
It starts with one principle that should not be compromised:
Health and safety should never be negotiable
Whether a rental property receives one star or five stars, certain requirements should always apply.
Every rental home should be structurally safe. Electrical installations should be safe. Gas appliances and installations should be safe where gas is present. Smoke alarms and fire-safety requirements should be met. There should be safe water, sanitation and functioning bathroom facilities. Serious building-related mould, damp and water penetration should be addressed. Doors, windows, stairs, balconies and other building elements should not present an unreasonable safety risk. They are fundamental requirements for safe housing, not luxury features.
Under the model being proposed here, a property that fails the health-and-safety test would not receive a lower star rating.
It simply would not be approved for rental until the health and safety problem was rectified.
The star rating would begin only after the property passed that test.
Safety is different from comfort
Safety vs comfort and amenity is where the discussion becomes more interesting. Safety isn't optional, but levels of comfort and efficiency can vary.
Is a house without double glazing unsafe? No.
Is a house without ceiling insulation necessarily unsafe? No.
Is a bedroom without air-conditioning automatically unsafe? Usually not.
Is an older but functional kitchen unsafe simply because it was installed in 1985? Of course not.
These features can make a property more comfortable, more energy efficient and cheaper to operate. Those are real benefits. But they are different from electrical hazards, gas leaks, structural failure, dangerous mould or inadequate sanitation.
Perhaps our rental regulations should recognise that distinction.
Victoria's rental standards are expanding
Victoria currently requires rental properties to satisfy mandatory minimum standards across areas including bathrooms, electrical safety, heating, kitchens, mould and damp, structural soundness, ventilation, toilets, locks and window coverings.
A fixed heater in the main living area is already compulsory.
From 1 March 2027, additional minimum energy-efficiency requirements begin phasing in across heating, cooling, hot water, showerheads, ceiling insulation and draught-proofing.
Among the changes, fixed energy-efficient cooling will generally be required when certain new rental agreements commence from March 2027, and from 1 July 2030 the cooling requirement extends to all Victorian rental properties, subject to applicable exemptions.
These reforms have stated objectives including improved comfort, lower household energy costs and reduced energy consumption.
Those are worthwhile objectives.
But there is another question worth examining:
At what point does continually increasing the minimum specification of every rental home begin to reduce the supply of lower-cost accommodation?
That question probably deserves proper economic analysis rather than an ideological answer.
What if rental properties were rated like hotels?
Hotels don't all provide the same level of accommodation. A traveller may choose a basic room because price matters most. Someone else may willingly pay considerably more for better facilities, climate control, larger rooms, premium bedding and higher-quality amenities.
Could a Rental Star Rating system operate under a similar, but much more carefully regulated system?
The Victorian Rental Star Rating System could look like this:
Rating | Indicative rental standard |
★ Essential | Safe, functional housing with limited comfort and energy-efficiency features |
★★ Basic | Basic comfort and some efficiency improvements |
★★★ Standard | Efficient heating and cooling in the main living area, reasonable insulation and comfort |
★★★★ Enhanced | Good insulation, efficient heating and cooling through most of the home, improved energy performance |
★★★★★ Premium | Excellent thermal performance, highly efficient whole-home climate control and very low operating costs |
The stars would not rate the suburb, school zone, size of the land or prestige of the address. Those things already influence market rent.
The rating system answers a much narrower question:
What level of accommodation, thermal comfort and energy efficiency does this particular home provide?
What would a one-star rental actually mean?
A one-star rental property should not mean an unsafe home. It should meet the basic health and safety requirements. But it may not have the heating and cooling or energy efficiency of a modern home. Consider an older but well-maintained house.
It might have:
no ceiling insulation
no air-conditioning
no fixed heating
single-glazed windows
an older kitchen
an older bathroom
limited energy efficiency.
Yet it could still be:
structurally sound
weatherproof
electrically safe
gas-safe where applicable
equipped with compliant smoke alarms
free from serious mould and damp
secure
sanitary
supplied with working hot water, toilet, shower and cooking facilities.
This is where the idea will understandably attract the most debate. Under a rental-rating model, that could be an:
★ Essential Rental
Its advertisement might clearly state:
Rental Quality Rating: ★☆☆☆☆
Health & Safety Assessment: PASS
Ceiling insulation: None
Fixed heating: None
Fixed cooling: None
Double glazing: No
Energy efficiency: Low
Approved portable electric heating/cooling: Permitted
It is basic accommodation: safe and functional, but with limited comfort and energy-efficiency features. There should be no fine print and no attempt to disguise the property's limitations.
The renter should know exactly what they are considering before they even inspect it.
Why would anyone choose a one-star rental?
Because people have different circumstances. Consider two otherwise comparable properties.
Property A
Rent: $420 per week
Rating: ★ Essential
Limited insulation.
No fixed cooling.
Higher expected energy consumption.
Property B
Rent: $540 per week
Rating: ★★★★ Enhanced
Good insulation.
Reverse-cycle heating and cooling.
Better glazing.
Efficient hot water.
Property B is clearly the superior home from a comfort and energy-efficiency perspective. But it costs another $120 per week. That's $6,240 per year in additional rent.
One household might happily pay the difference. Another might decide that paying roughly $520 more each month in rent is not worth the additional comfort and potential energy savings, and consciously accept higher energy use and lower thermal comfort in exchange for saving more than $6,200 a year in rent.
A university student may make one decision.
A household with young children may make another.
A pensioner may have different priorities again.
Someone who spends half the year overseas may value heating and cooling very differently from somebody who works from home five days a week.
It is not a one-size-fits-all situation. There isn't necessarily one correct answer for all of them.
But isn't a poorly insulated home more expensive to run?
Potentially, yes. And this is one of the strongest arguments in favour of higher energy-efficiency standards. A cheaper rental isn't necessarily cheaper when household energy costs are included. That is why a proper star-rating system should disclose more than just stars.
A rental advertisement could eventually show something like:
Rent: $420 per week
Rental Quality: ★★☆☆☆
Estimated energy performance: Poor
compared with:
Rent: $470 per week
Rental Quality: ★★★★☆
Estimated energy performance: Very Good
This would allow renters to consider total occupancy cost, not merely weekly rent.
The purpose of disclosure should be to provide better information, not to pretend that low-efficiency housing has no disadvantages.
Would one-star housing create a lower class of rental accommodation?
That's another legitimate concern. If inexpensive one-star rentals were concentrated in lower-income suburbs, critics could argue that lower-income households would disproportionately live in less comfortable and less efficient housing.
But there is another side to that issue. Many Australian inner-city suburbs already contain large numbers of older homes with modest energy efficiency performance. Some are rental properties. Many others are owner-occupied. People live in those homes today, every day. And many more renters actively value them, because of their location and comparatively lower rent.
They aren't necessarily unsafe. Some could ultimately leave the rental market if they fail to meet new requirements and the owner is unwilling or unable to undertake the necessary upgrades.
They are simply older housing stock. And older, less highly specified housing has historically played an important role in providing lower-cost accommodation.
If every older property must progressively be upgraded towards a significantly higher specification before it can legally be rented, some owners may upgrade. Others may sell. Some may redevelop. Others may decide that continuing to provide the property as a rental is no longer worthwhile.
There could ultimately be a negative effect on rental supply and, in turn, rents. As supply shrinks, rents will go up, if demand does not reduce.
The outcome isn't necessarily straightforward. This issue needs independent economic modelling.
A safe old home does not automatically become unsafe when a new renter moves in
There is an interesting consistency question here.
Imagine a 1970s Melbourne brick-veneer house. Its owner has lived there happily for 25 years.
It has single glazing.
Its insulation is basic.
There is one old heater.
There is no air-conditioning.
The owner sells it to another owner-occupier.
Nobody argues the house should suddenly be prohibited from occupation solely because its thermal performance is mediocre.
But if that same house becomes a rental property, it may be required to undergo upgrades that an owner-occupier living in the identical home is not required to undertake, depending on which rental standards and transition provisions apply.
There may be good policy reasons for treating rental housing differently. Renters generally cannot make substantial alterations to someone else's building, while owner-occupiers can choose whether to improve their own home.
But it is still worth asking:
Which features genuinely belong to an absolute habitability standard, and which features are better treated as differences in accommodation quality?
A possible five-star framework to address increasingly high standards
A more developed system could separate rental regulation into two layers. A Health and Safety layer and a Rental Quality Rating layer.
Layer 1: Mandatory Health & Safety
Every property must pass this basic level. Health and safety requirements should never be negotiable.
This could cover:
structural integrity
electrical safety
gas safety
smoke and fire safety
serious mould and damp
weatherproofing
sanitary bathroom and toilet facilities
potable water
functioning hot water
safe cooking facilities
safe ventilation
Failure = cannot rent.
No renter should be able to waive these requirements.
Layer 2: Rental Quality Rating
Once the property passes the tests in the first layer it is rated on more comfort, amenity and features such as:
ceiling insulation
wall and floor insulation
glazing
draught sealing
heating
cooling
heating and cooling to bedrooms
hot-water efficiency
solar
window coverings
kitchen amenity
bathroom amenity
ventilation
overall condition
predicted energy performance.
This rating then produces the ★ to ★★★★★ rating.
Landlords shouldn't be allowed to deliberately downgrade homes
Any rating system would also need anti-gaming rules. Imagine a property currently has three perfectly good reverse-cycle air-conditioners. A landlord shouldn't be able to remove them simply to turn the property into a cheaper one-star rental.
Similarly, if a property was leased with heating, cooling, an oven or another functioning appliance, a lower star rating should not remove the landlord's responsibility to maintain the facilities actually provided under the tenancy.
The objective should be to preserve the standard of the property as initially leased, not create an incentive for landlords to strip functional amenities from better homes.
Rent controls shouldn't be attached to the stars
Much like the hotel star rating system, the star rating system should not determine prescribed rents according to ratings. Market forces should be allowed to function.
For example:
★ properties may charge $400.
★★★ properties may charge $550.
★★★★★ properties may charge $750.
Rent should be determined by market forces, not government legislation.
If the market determines there is a 50% premium for a 5-star 4 bedroom house in Glen Waverley, so be it. The same market force in a different suburb may also determine the 5-star property is not worth more than 20% premium. Similarly, the 5-star house in a regional town where residents are happy with a 2-star property, it will not command the same premium regardless of their thermal performance.
Location, land, bedroom count, transport, schools, condition and local supply and demand all affect rental price. The star system should therefore provide information, not determine the rent. Let market forces determine the rents.
Different locations may also reveal very different willingness to pay for higher-rated accommodation. In some markets, renters may place a substantial premium on five-star comfort and efficiency. In others, affordability may matter more and the rental premium for additional stars may be relatively small. The market data would eventually tell us, and accommodation providers can tailor their product to meet the needs of the market.
Over time, the rental market would reveal how much renters are prepared to pay for additional comfort and efficiency.
That information itself could become valuable.
Imagine being able to see:
Median three-bedroom ★★ rental: $510/week
Median three-bedroom ★★★ rental: $545/week
Median three-bedroom ★★★★ rental: $595/week
Renters could make better comparisons.
Owners could then decide whether spending the $15,000 to upgrade from ★★ to ★★★★ would produce an economic return. And policymakers could determine the demand for the types of rental properties in different locations, and measure whether efficiency improvements genuinely translate into lower total household costs.
Isn't it simpler to continue raising minimum standards?
That remains a legitimate policy option. There are strong arguments for it. Better insulation and efficient heating and cooling can improve comfort. Energy-efficient homes can reduce energy consumption. Renters often cannot justify investing substantial amounts of money upgrading homes they don't own.
Mandatory standards can solve that split-incentive problem. But mandatory standards have costs as well. Someone ultimately pays for insulation, heating systems, cooling systems, hot-water upgrades and other improvements.
It is usually the property owner absorbing the costs, but some of the cost may ultimately be reflected in higher rents.
Some owners may instead sell, reducing rental properties available for rent and potentially placing further pressure on supply.
The overall consequences depend on housing supply, vacancy rates, upgrade costs, tenant demand and many other variables.
In a market already experiencing tight rental supply and high property holding costs, additional compliance costs may place upward pressure on rents or affect an owner's decision to remain in the rental market. The size of that effect should be independently measured rather than assumed.
Perhaps the question isn't “meet standards or do not meet standards”
That is probably the wrong debate. The better question might be:
Which standards should be absolutely compulsory, and which should be transparently rated?
Electrical safety? Compulsory.
Fire safety? Compulsory.
Structural safety? Compulsory.
Serious mould and damp? Compulsory.
Safe sanitation? Compulsory.
Air-conditioning in every bedroom? Perhaps that belongs in the rating.
Double glazing? Perhaps rating.
R5 ceiling insulation? Perhaps rating.
Solar panels? Rating.
Whole-home reverse-cycle climate control? Almost certainly rating.
There is still consultation needed to decide exactly where that line should sit.
What about existing energy-rating systems?
Australia does not necessarily need to start from nothing. Existing home-energy assessment frameworks can measure aspects of thermal and energy performance.
A future rental-quality rating could potentially incorporate recognised energy-performance assessments while adding other rental-specific factors such as heating and cooling coverage, amenities and property condition.
The objective should not be another expensive bureaucracy simply for the sake of creating one.
The rating should be easy for renters to understand, practical for owners to obtain and sufficiently consistent that two similar homes receive broadly comparable assessments.
What would success look like?
A successful system wouldn't necessarily mean every Victorian rental eventually becomes five stars. That may actually defeat the purpose.
A healthy rental housing market could contain different products for different households. It should allow investors and property owners to offer lower-cost rental properties, if the renters prefer them.
Such a market could contain:
★ affordable basic housing.
★★ functional older housing.
★★★ mainstream comfortable accommodation.
★★★★ highly efficient housing.
★★★★★ premium accommodation.
What matters is that every rental property is safe. The renter then has meaningful information about what is being offered and how much it costs.
Could the Victorian Rental Star Rating System Improve Housing Affordability?
Possibly. But it needs testing. A rental-rating model could preserve older, lower-cost accommodation that might otherwise require significant capital expenditure before it could continue being rented.
It could allow property owners to continue to lease these more basic properties at a lower price. It could also encourage owners to voluntarily upgrade because higher ratings may command stronger rents, lower vacancy or better tenant demand.
Those competing effects should be modelled rather than assumed.
A sensible next step could therefore be a pilot program comparing:
actual rents
energy consumption
tenant satisfaction
vacancy periods
maintenance costs
upgrade costs
landlord investment behaviour
total renter housing costs.
That evidence would tell us far more than slogans from either side of the rental debate.
The proposal in one sentence
Perhaps the principle is this:
Every renter should have the right to safe housing. But adults could also have the right to knowingly choose between safe basic accommodation and more expensive housing offering greater comfort, amenities and energy efficiency.
That doesn't mean the rental standards are obsolete. It requires deciding which standards genuinely protect health and safety and which standards describe the quality of the accommodation being purchased.
A transparent star-rating system may offer one way to do that. It may not be the final answer.
But with housing affordability becoming increasingly difficult for many Australians, the question deserves serious discussion.
What do you think?
Would you knowingly rent a safe, properly disclosed ★ or ★★ property if it saved you $80, $100 or $150 per week?
Or do you believe heating, cooling, insulation and other efficiency standards should continue becoming universal minimum requirements regardless of rental price?
And where would you draw the line between essential safety and optional comfort?
I'd particularly like to hear from renters, rental providers, property managers, builders, energy-efficiency professionals, housing researchers and consumer advocates.
A better rental system should ultimately be judged by whether it produces safe homes, sufficient housing supply, genuine consumer choice and housing people can afford.
FAQ
Are one-star rentals currently legal in Victoria?
No such rating currently exists under Victorian rental law. Victorian rental properties must comply with the applicable statutory minimum standards. The one-to-five-star framework described here is a policy proposal for discussion.
Would a one-star rental be allowed to have unsafe wiring or dangerous mould?
No. Under the proposed model, health and safety requirements are not optional and would apply equally to every rental property. A property failing those requirements would not be eligible to rent, regardless of its star rating.
Would landlords be able to charge more for higher-rated properties?
The proposal would not set rents according to star ratings. Market rents would continue to reflect location, property size, condition, supply, demand and amenities. The rating would provide additional information about the quality and efficiency of the accommodation, allowing renters to decide whether any premium is worth paying.
Would renters be forced to accept one-star properties?
No. The premise is informed choice. The property's rating and material shortcomings would need to be disclosed before a renter applies or enters into an agreement.
Are Victoria's rental energy-efficiency standards changing?
Yes. New minimum energy-efficiency standards covering heating, cooling, hot water, showerheads, ceiling insulation and draughtproofing begin phasing in from 1 March 2027.
Does Victoria currently require heating in rental properties?
Yes. Victorian rental properties currently require a fixed heater in good working order in the main living area, subject to the applicable minimum-standard rules.
This article discusses a possible alternative policy framework. It does not describe current Victorian rental law. Rental providers and renters should refer to Consumer Affairs Victoria for current minimum rental standards and compliance requirements.
Current Victorian rental-standard information checked: 27 October 2026.
Rayson L. is Director and Buyers Advocate at Concierge Buyers Advocates in Melbourne. He works with home buyers, property investors and renters across the Victorian property market and writes about property acquisition, housing policy and market trends.




Comments